religion, christianity, articles
Firm Foundation Logo

Studies in the Restoration

By L. L. Brigance

religion, articles, christianity

(Leonard Lee Brigance, 1879 to 1950, was a professor of Bible at Freed Hardeman College for many years. His logical mind enabled him to transmit clear, clean-cut thoughts. He was a writer for the Gospel Advocate and in the early '40s composed a number of articles titled "Studies in the Restoration. " He dealt at length with the Christian Church [Disciples of Christ] and demonstrated its drift into liberalism and oblivion. Since the church now has a number of capable men who are tracking the Disciples' disaster, some of the Brigance articles are being reprinted. It is fabulous that brother Brigance more than 50 years ago described conditions now evident in the church - Dobbs.)

There was a time when all those who constituted the Restoration Movement believed that the Bible was inspired of God, that it was infallibly correct, that it constituted our supreme and sole authority in spiritual things, that there was revealed in the New Testament a pattern of the one-and-only church approved of God, that it was fixed and permanent, that the "plan of salvation" was explicitly set forth, that it was inflexible - in short, that we had to find authority in the New Testament for everything we believed or practiced in religion. But alas! Times have changed. A part of that movement has abandoned practically every one of the above propositions. The left wing of the big "D" Disciples have given up the "back-to-Jerusalem," "back-to-the-apostles" plea of the pioneers and are now headed toward Rome, Geneva, London, or some other place unknown to the Bible, unless it be Gehenna. They have given up the undenominational plea for "unity through the restoration of the New Testament church," have fraternized with denominationalism, endorsed it, and, in fact, are one themselves. DeGroot, in discussing the relation of the Disciples to "church federation," says:

Whether the Disciples were, or are, a denomination or not (which, of course, is purely a matter of definition), the fact is that they soon presented the normal characteristics of a functioning denomination, with "our" plea, "our" conventions, and "our" agencies. The Disciples came up in the error of the federation idea looking and acting (though not talking) like a denomination.

Thus they are beginning to admit their denominationalism, and no doubt in a few years they will do it freely and unblushingly. If they were not speaking the language of Ashdod (denominationalism) then, they are now, and in all essentials are just another denomination.

The Model Church

Is there a model or pattern of the church that Jesus said he would build revealed in the Scriptures? Did the apostles through whom Christ built the church have a blueprint and specifications, figuratively speaking, to guide them in its erection? Let us see.

The need of patterns in material things. In nearly all of the relationships of life man must have patterns, models, and standards to guide and govern him in whatever he does. Is he about to build a house? He must have a pattern, a blueprint, and specifications either on paper or in his mind. He cannot build without it. The garment maker generally has a pattern by which to cut a gown and then a model on which to shape it. One of the most important workmen in a foundry is the patternmaker. Every piece of metal must be molded (modeled) according to the pattern. In buying and selling, trading and trafficking, there must be standards by which to be governed. The commerce of the world could not be carried on without units of measurement - units of length, capacity, value, etc. They must be authoritative, constant, and permanent.

The need of Patterns in spiritual things. Because of their greater importance there is more need for models, patterns, and standards in spiritual things than in material things. There is need for a model after which each individual Christian can mold his life - his character and conduct. Then there is need for a pattern according to which groups of Christians may organize for work and worship.

Jesus Christ is the model for every Christian life (John 13:15; Phil 2:5; 1 Pet. 2:21; 4:1). He is a perfect model. His perfection is the goal that every follower of him must strive to reach. The fact that no one can imitate him perfectly does not keep him from being our example, nor does it justify us in not doing our best. He ever leads the way. We can never overtake him; but, nevertheless, he calls upon us to follow him.

The church of the New Testament is a divine model or pattern of what God would have groups of Christians everywhere to be. It is so clearly outlined that its essential characteristics can be readily discerned by everyone who is sincerely seeking them. As a spiritual institution it is perfect. The standard of work, worship, and conduct of its members is perfect. But because of the weaknesses of men, this standard will rarely, if ever, be met. Nevertheless, God cannot lower the standard, else he would appear to be satisfied with imperfection, which would be incompatible with his very nature.

The Tabernacle and the Church

It is assumed that the readers of this paper believe the Jewish tabernacle built by Moses in the wilderness was a type of the church (Heb. 9:1-10). God gave Moses a pattern of the tabernacle and the "instruments thereof' (Ex. 25:9) and charged him to "make them after the pattern, which was shewed thee in the mount" (v. 40; Heb. 8:5). This charge was emphasized by several repetitions. The workmen who were to build the tabernacle were inspired of God (Ex. 31:1-11). In the specifications the dimensions of the tabernacle and every piece of furniture, the amount and different kinds of material to be used, with all necessary instructions, were given to the minutest detail. Moses did everything as God commanded him. When it was finished and all things were ready, God took up his abode in it, and his glory filled it.

Corresponding to all of this is the church. For more than three years Jesus taught his disciples concerning the kingdom, the church, the house of God. Even during the 40-day interval between the resurrection and the ascension, he taught them the things "pertaining to the kingdom of God." What was he doing? Creating in their minds a pattern of the church. But he was not willing to risk them then to follow his instructions without divine assistance. So he ordered them to wait until they were "endued with power from on high." So "when the day of Pentecost was fully come, ... they were all filled with the Holy Ghost, and began to speak with other tongues, as the Spirit gave them utterance." Being baptized in the Holy Spirit, completely under his control, all that they said and did on that occasion was directed by him. The gospel was preached; the people heard it; they were pricked in their hearts - convinced, convicted, made to believe; they were told to repent and be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and they would receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. As many as received his word were baptized, and there were added to them that day about three thousand souls; and they continued steadfastly in the apostles' teaching and fellowship and in the breaking of bread and in prayers; and the Lord added to the church daily such as were being saved (Acts 2).

The Jerusalem Church

Here we have the first church of God on earth. Every step in its establishment was directed by the Holy Spirit through the apostles. It continued to be guided by these inspired men throughout its entire history. It must, therefore, have been perfect except for human imperfections - they render all man does imperfect, even his obedience to God. Aside from that, the Jerusalem church must have been just such a church as God approved - a model church, so far as its experiences went.

It may be admitted in advance of special examination that the Jerusalem church did not pass through all the experiences which congregations have since encountered, and that, therefore, it had no possible opportunity to set us an example for such experiences; and yet it may still be for us a perfect model to the extent of the experiences through which it was called to pass (McGarvey).

Perhaps there is no one church or congregation mentioned in the New Testament that stands as a complete model of the church, because its expressed characteristics do not cover the whole ground, but rather the "model church" is a composite church made up of all the examples of, and precepts to, the New Testament churches.

In our next article we will undertake to set forth the essential characteristics of this "model church."

(Brother Brigance taught Bible at Freed Hardeman College for 42 years. He was a bright star in his generation, though he never thought of himself as such. His works follow with him. When Brigance died, Perry Cotham wrote, "He has had a great part in preparing young men to preach the gospel; I am grateful that I had the opportunity of being one among that number " Basil Overton called him "a servant of God of no mean ability. " In future articles it will be apparent that the fatal direction of the Christian Church, which brother Brigance so ably and accurately described, is the same course being stubbornly pursued by a few of our contemporaries - we do not say colleagues out of respect to the brilliant L. L. Brigance - Dobbs.)

Feature Book: Among the Scholars


by David W. Hester

Paperback, 167 pages
$7.99 + shipping and tax if applicable


Click here to order


Published November 1993